Use 64-bit products in actual monthly fund/property settlement, monthly and annual previews, and weekly dividend offers. Retain per-unit rounding, recipient policy and final native fields. Test representable high-value settlements against their forecasts. Full 32-bit money storage overflow remains unresolved. Refs: #46
157 lines
11 KiB
Markdown
157 lines
11 KiB
Markdown
# Compatibility decisions
|
||
|
||
OpenBMH aims to preserve the familiar game while handling malformed input and unsafe edge cases explicitly. A reconstruction can remain faithful without reproducing a crash or pretending to implement an unknown path.
|
||
|
||
- Content such as names, text, graphics and edition-specific tables is loaded from the user's installation. The loaded program retains its own rule-table values; loading no longer applies the former shared replacement profile.
|
||
- Safety checks reject transactions that would exhaust required return capacity, use stale identities or lose a valid state. Unsupported operations report their limitation rather than inventing an outcome.
|
||
- Calendar progression handles boundary days and seasonal transitions without relying on unsafe fixed-day assumptions.
|
||
- Saves are written from the committed session state. Saving does not deliberately replay unrelated game actions.
|
||
- The reconstruction uses two deterministic random generators with explicit integer semantics. This supports reproducible runs, but is not a promise of complete bit-for-bit equivalence to every original edition or across changed engine versions.
|
||
|
||
Intentional changes in code should use the marker `OpenBMH deviates from the original:` and explain their purpose. Adding a new behaviour or balance change requires a concrete description and relevant tests; this page is not permission to substitute guessed rules.
|
||
|
||
The [generated differences catalogue](DIFFERENCES.md) lists these markers with links to their source files.
|
||
|
||
## Application exit confirmation
|
||
|
||
Closing the window, exiting with Escape or confirming the desktop's exit control
|
||
opens a native confirmation dialog. BMH data uses German text and Football
|
||
Limited data uses English. Enter, Escape and closing the confirmation cancel the
|
||
exit; only the explicit Quit/Beenden button permits normal shutdown. Cancelling
|
||
keeps the current dialog or match owner alive without a turn or implicit save.
|
||
An unavailable native message box also cancels the request. This applies to
|
||
voluntary application exits, including quit events received during animations;
|
||
normal completed-career handling remains separate.
|
||
|
||
## Original edition rules in 1.0
|
||
|
||
Loaded executable images retain their own rule tables. Career strength ranges are read from all nine pairs of the supplied original table.
|
||
|
||
The six-budget monthly environment implementation has been checked against the provided CD and Diamond 3.6/3.7 program code. Its budget increments are read from that program's own table. Capability recognition uses verified code fingerprints, never directory names. Unrecognized environment implementations cannot be edited or simulated through a guessed model; they require separate compatibility verification. Older Diamond academy patches are not silently treated as the monthly model. The old floppy executable remains unsupported, and Football Limited remains experimental.
|
||
|
||
Release acceptance of individual editions is recorded separately from their recognition. Source compatibility and automated tests do not establish full original-game or platform validation.
|
||
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: graphical startup shows the supplied static
|
||
137.VGA title with its embedded palette, without the DOS loading animation.
|
||
It waits for a complete left or right mouse click before the game options.
|
||
The title does not advance on a timer; its confirming press and release are
|
||
consumed so they cannot also change a setup option.
|
||
|
||
Setup restores ordinary scene-backed manager dialogs before a career is created
|
||
or loaded. The executable's boot-only black dialog mode is process state and is
|
||
not restored from native save files. Football Limited's translated data includes
|
||
its own verified calendar year and weekday operands; German epochs are not used
|
||
as a substitute for the English edition.
|
||
|
||
## Diamond 3.7 foreign crests
|
||
|
||
The supplied edition controls whether foreign league clubs use individual
|
||
original crests or the original neutral crest. OpenBMH recognizes the verified
|
||
Diamond 3.7 drawing gate and uses its database/save selectors and W atlases.
|
||
Older drawing gates retain their own behaviour; no external crest pack is needed.
|
||
|
||
The automatic lineup installs the supplied foreign-player rule switch alongside the career tables. Where enabled, it restores the original three/two-player limit, reserve swaps with board-coordinate preservation and the short-lineup outcome when domestic reserves are unavailable. This does not consume additional random draws.
|
||
|
||
New careers correct the original all-zero EM qualification placeholders to the original national-team placeholders. Supplied nonzero seeds and restored savegame state are not rewritten by this initialization.
|
||
|
||
## Stadium extension in1.0.3
|
||
|
||
The user-requested stadium extension raises standard A–H maxima to14/24/14/20/
|
||
14/24/14/20thousand places (144,000total), keeping larger supplied custom limits
|
||
where the saved byte fields can represent them. Original unit prices remain
|
||
edition-owned. Each stand's base build period is at least two weeks per1,000
|
||
places of its expanded maximum and never shorter than the edition's original
|
||
period. Contractor shortening remains unchanged.
|
||
|
||
The original Diamond3.6/3.7 table's14k stands really used25weeks versus30weeks
|
||
for8k and37weeks for18k. That was original data, not a mistaken timer. Expanded
|
||
limits/time policy is an intentional improvement. The UI now validates quotes
|
||
against the actual edition and this shared policy rather than hardcoded Diamond
|
||
prices and sizes. Existing eight capacity/construction bytes and saves are retained.
|
||
## Daily interest at large native balances
|
||
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: daily debt and deposit interest uses 64-bit
|
||
intermediate arithmetic before the original integer divisions. The balance-plan
|
||
preview uses the same calculation. Original rates, division order and random
|
||
consumption remain unchanged. Account balances and accumulated statistics retain
|
||
the native 32-bit save representation; this change does not add unlimited account
|
||
balances or change the original high-cash deduction policy.
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: the legacy transfer market allows an owned
|
||
listing to open incoming offers before its weekly expiry. Select the player and
|
||
use the sale action (or Enter). Cancel keeps the listing and offers unchanged;
|
||
acceptance uses the existing buyer eligibility, player salary qualification and
|
||
transaction rules. Human-buyer loans still require their separate consent and
|
||
allocator context and are unavailable in this early review. Viewing/canceling
|
||
consumes no RNG. The weekly auction remains unchanged.
|
||
|
||
The transfer overview processes one selected player per action and renders action
|
||
feedback in its footer. A cleared unsuccessful listing can be listed again
|
||
immediately; there is no additional cooldown. The manager listing action refuses a full ordinary market
|
||
without allocating a reserved special-offer row. These are explicit
|
||
application outcomes instead of the Original's destructive overflow/dialog paths.
|
||
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: a newly initialized squad board entry clears
|
||
retirement, refused-negotiation and month-processing flags left by its previous
|
||
occupant. The Original leaves that byte intact when reusing the row, so purchases
|
||
and academy arrivals can inherit a refusal to renew. Existing players' genuine
|
||
retirement/refusal flags remain effective. The initial academy contract remains
|
||
two years; a young arrival can immediately negotiate any supported renewal term.
|
||
This corrects the reused-row mechanism; it does not establish a fixed 200–300
|
||
season threshold or repair ambiguous refusal flags in existing saved careers.
|
||
|
||
Bank finance-overview totals and gains use 64-bit read-only projections and
|
||
currency formatting, including values beyond a signed native account word.
|
||
Saved cash, deposits, loan fields and holdings retain their original widths.
|
||
This prevents a positive combined portfolio from appearing negative; it does
|
||
not recover amounts that have already overflowed inside a native saved field.
|
||
|
||
Live ball, set-piece and shot animations retain
|
||
visible scoreboard digits at the chance-preview value until the result view.
|
||
The simulation still commits goals, statistics and random draws at their existing
|
||
boundaries. Post-match overview dismissal owns its full mouse gesture, including
|
||
release after pointer movement, before the following calendar decision can open.
|
||
The pitch uses each edition's original position-distance tables, atlas swatches
|
||
and pointer bitmap for placement feedback; this display state is not serialized.
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: cumulative human-club appearances, goals and
|
||
assists have optional 64-bit counters. Original byte/word fields keep their
|
||
modulo representation for gameplay/layout compatibility; roster projections use
|
||
the wider values. Tracking begins with the surviving legacy values, so high bits
|
||
already lost in an imported save cannot be recovered. A new arrival clears the
|
||
previous squad occupant's totals. Club promotion remaps counter ownership.
|
||
|
||
Title-holder and cup-winner lists retain all observed seasons in the same optional
|
||
OpenBMH save extension. The Original nine-by-fifty table remains a rolling window.
|
||
The archive captures that window before it shifts, and the title list can page
|
||
through the archived rows. Late legacy imports start with their surviving fifty
|
||
seasons; earlier winners are unknown and are not fabricated. Stored winner names
|
||
are historical snapshots, so later renaming and promotion cannot change them.
|
||
The separate manager-achievements graph retains its Original fifty-season view.
|
||
|
||
These records use a versioned `OBMHEXT1` extension after the Original name pools;
|
||
see [save format](formats/LONG_CAREER.md). Original programs and older OpenBMH
|
||
writers do not preserve this archive. Keep an OpenBMH backup when exchanging
|
||
careers with those writers. The native calendar still has its existing signed
|
||
16-bit season limit; this patch does not claim an unlimited calendar.
|
||
## Monthly high-cash loss limit
|
||
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: the high-cash bank robbery can occur at most
|
||
once per manager and calendar month. The original threshold above 100 million
|
||
and random loss of 10–20 million remain. A blocked repeat consumes no random
|
||
draw. Month boundaries follow the same source calendar used by daily processing,
|
||
and the guard is stored in the optional BRM1 section of OBMHEXT1 saves.
|
||
|
||
An older save has no record of past robberies. Its first qualifying high-cash month
|
||
receives a grace period without a loss or random draw; subsequent saves retain
|
||
that guard. The next calendar month can trigger the ordinary loss. Import cannot
|
||
infer whether an event already occurred before this feature. Fresh histories
|
||
receive the same initial grace month.
|
||
|
||
|
||
OpenBMH deviates from the original: monthly fund/property dividends multiply
|
||
unit price by the dividend factor in 64 bits before the existing integer division.
|
||
The monthly and annual previews and weekly offers use the same widened product.
|
||
Per-unit rounding and the selected legacy/typed recipient policy are unchanged.
|
||
This corrects intermediate overflow for representable dividends; account,
|
||
deposit, property book value and monthly totals still use their native 32-bit
|
||
storage and can overflow. It is not a complete large-balance finance fix.
|